Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Search representations

Results for Historic England (East Midlands) search

New search New search

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 15: What do you think of the draft site specific allocation for brick clay?

Representation ID: 32277

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

The proposed allocation at Woodborough Lane (MP6c) should consider any archaeological impacts and any relevant matter should be addressed in the Appendix 3 draft development brief.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 16: What do you think of the draft site specific allocation for Gypsum?

Representation ID: 32278

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

It is not clear from the draft Plan information how the proposed allocation at Bantycock Quarry South (MP7c) has been considered in relation to the historic environment since the Appendix 3 draft development plan does not refer to heritage assets or their setting. We would want to better understand the significance of the Shire Dyke as an historic landscape feature and integrate links with its natural environment. It is not clear how any archaeological impacts have been considered.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 18: What do you think of the draft policy to meet demand for industrial dolomite over the plan period?

Representation ID: 32279

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

MP9 general approach is not supported as known sources are limited and therefore the policy provides a de facto site allocation. Also, the policy ignores the environmental and other social and economic factors that must be balanced by saying an application would be supported where a need can be demonstrated.

The Holbeck site is also near Cresswell Crags which is on the tentative list of potential UNESCO WHS. This is likely to include a buffer which will limit traffic movement and extraction.

Extraction at Holbeck would constitute substantial harm to designated heritage assets of the highest importance.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 19: What do you think of the draft policy to meet demand for building stone over the plan period?

Representation ID: 32280

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

Historic England welcomes the approach to the provision of building stone. The policy provisions would potentially assist with heritage repairs and ensuring local distinctiveness.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 20: What do you think of the draft policy to meet demand for coal over the plan period?

Representation ID: 32281

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

Historic England has no concerns with the proposed approach in respect of the demand for coal as set out in draft Policy MP11: Coal.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 21: What do you think of the draft policy to meet demand for hydrocarbons over the plan period?

Representation ID: 32282

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

Historic England has no concerns to raise in respect of the proposed approach to hydrocarbon minerals as set out in draft Policy MP12: Hydrocarbons.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 27: What do you think of the draft policy wording for DM6: Historic environment

Representation ID: 32283

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

Historic England has concerns in relation to the wording of draft Policy DM6 and considers it not to be sound. Criteria a) refers to 'adverse impact' rather than harm and Criterion b) and c) refer to 'harm or loss' and the mitigation of loss against public harm. The draft policy is not in accordance with the stepped approach advocated in the NPPF.

the draft Policy is not worded positively and it is recommended that this be reviewed prior to the next iteration of the Plan.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 33: What do you think of the draft policy wording for DM12: Restoration,after-use and aftercare?

Representation ID: 32284

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

Historic England welcomes the provisions set out for the historic environment in draft Policy DM12.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 11: What do you think of the draft site specific sand and gravel allocations?

Representation ID: 32285

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

Site MP2l has archaeological potential. It is recognized that appendix 3 says that this would have to be considered in a planning proposal and that there is this potential. It is recommended hat the historic environment elements are brought together in the development brief and clarify what should be submitted as part of a development proposal.

For non-designated archaeology, the council should be satisfied that extraction work could take place, if not then there is an issue of soundness.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 11: What do you think of the draft site specific sand and gravel allocations?

Representation ID: 32286

Received: 29/09/2018

Respondent: Historic England (East Midlands)

Representation Summary:

It is noted that the Appendix 3 site allocation development brief highlights the 'high potential for the site to contain non-designated archaeology'.

In terms of the high potential for non-designated archaeology, is the Council satisfied that the anticipated extraction work could take place? If not, there is an issue of soundnessn and it is likely that further investigative work is required as part of the Plan process prior to any allocation.

Furthermore, it is not clear from the development brief information what kind of archaeological investigations and/or WSI would be expected as part of an application.

For instructions on how to use the system and make comments, please see our help guide.