Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Search representations

Results for Mick George search

New search New search

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 1: What do you think of the draft vision and strategic objectives?

Representation ID: 32392

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

SO1: Aspiration of policy is sound however very little unused aggregate available
SO1: Prioritising extensions to quarries over new quarries is misguided and contary to national policy.
SO6 & SO8 There is a conflict between biodiversity led restoration and Protecting agricultural soils.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 3: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for minerals provision?

Representation ID: 32393

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

MGL opposes Policy 5P2 - Mineral Provision and in particular part b} of the strategy which is to give priority to the extension of existing sites. Not only is this contrary to national policy and guidance, but it also entrenches an uncompetitive market by nakedly preferring incumbent operators and raising barriers to entry to the local aggregates market to new firms, and it has not been shown to be justified by evidence.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 3: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for minerals provision?

Representation ID: 32394

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

MGL also doubts that the level of provision has been arrived at with due regard to part d) of the strategy since the way the provision has been calculated fails to take account of such wider economic trends.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 4: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for biodiversity led restoration?

Representation ID: 32395

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

MGL objects in particular part 1 of the policy which does not clarify sufficiently the potential conflict with the type of restoration sought and the need to preserve the long term potential of best and most versatile soils. Paragraph 3.23 contains some guidance on what habitats might be created there is no specific allowance for restoration to agriculture where it is necessary to retain the best and most versatile soils. MGL is seeking the acknowledgement that agricultural afteruses are still important for the best soils which is contained in paragraph 3.28, for inclusion in the policy to aid clarification of potentially conflicting objectives.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 6: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for sustainable transport?

Representation ID: 32396

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

Firstly. If the preference for extensions and their claimed lack of environmental impact is partly based on the availability of infrastructure or potential for barge transport, and this is a major consideration in the choice of a site for inclusion in the plan, then MGL considers that such transport ought to become mandatory for a proportion of the proposed development.
Secondly. Minimising transportation of mineral is a major consideration. Therefore the plan should actively seek to provide minerals supplies indigenously in accordance with national policy and should repatriate material imported from other areas, if it can be supplied locally.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 7: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for the built, historic and natural environment?

Representation ID: 32397

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

Policy SP6 does not deal with potential conflicts between different policy areas, nor provide advice on where the balance lies when considering such conflicts . Our major concern is the conflict between a biodiversity led restoration policy approach and the need to conserve best and most versatile soil.
MGL believes what is needed is a statement about the level of acceptable losses of best and most versatile soils (say, limited to less than 20 ha) and an indication of how to minimise such losses even if this should be at the expense of less wetland habitat.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 7: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for the built, historic and natural environment?

Representation ID: 32398

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

20. Regarding infrastructure in paragraph 3.66 the Local Plan is in danger of mispresenting the legal situation. Not all infrastructure has rights of absolute protection. Utility companies install below ground infrastructure under explicit title provision that should the land and mineral owners wish to extract minerals then either the apparatus is removed or compensation is paid when the working face approaches the pipeline and a statutory notice is served. This is a commercial matter and the planning system should not be used to subvert the legitimate rights of landowners under other codes. Accordingly, paragraph 3.66 should be modified

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 10: What do you think of the draft policy approach regarding future aggregate provision?

Representation ID: 32399

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

MGL considers that the Local Plan severely under-provides for sand and gravel. In particular, reliance on a bare 10 year average past sales as a forecast of future demand is clearly not appropriate on its own . Thus the Local Plan does not take into account planned development so that the LAA 'forecast' is based entirely on past sales trends contrary to national policy and guidance.
Two different methodologies have been put forward that would require either 2.8 million tonnes per annum or 2.4 million tonnes per annum.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 11: What do you think of the draft site specific sand and gravel allocations?

Representation ID: 32400

Received: 25/09/2018

Respondent: Mick George

Representation Summary:

MGL has no comment about the specifics of the allocations except to reiterate the need for more provision in the form of new quarries and a more equitable spread of sites among the industry. Thus MGL wishes to promote is own site at Flash Farm, Averham.

For instructions on how to use the system and make comments, please see our help guide.