Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Search representations

Results for Tarmac search

New search New search

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 11: What do you think of the draft site specific sand and gravel allocations?

Representation ID: 32438

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

Tarmac are supportive of the approach to work permitted reserves as well as allocating extensions to existing operations and through the provision of new greenfield sites. However there needs to be an allowance in the Plan for both non-allocated extensions and new greenfield sites to come forward to provide flexibility. There should not be a sole reliance on quarries physical location in the county. Disappointed that Besthorpe quarry east was not allocated and there is a clear need for the North Road east quarry and Burridge Farm proposals.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 12: What do you think of the draft site specific Sherwood Sandstone allocations?

Representation ID: 32439

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

The LAA recognises the high level of export to markets outside the County due to limited resources elsewhere. As per comments on sand and gravel, there is a need where resource exists to maintain production and operating capacity to meet demand. The Plan should identify appropriate extensions to existing operations or new sites to meet demand. Identified demand based on sales is a minimum requirement of the Plan and there should be flexibility built into the Plan to allow sites to come forward.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 13: What do you think of the draft policy to meet demand for crushed rock over the plan period?

Representation ID: 32440

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

It is likely that there is a wider demand for crushed rock within the County than that met by Nether Langwith. Crushed rock requirements are likely to be met from imports to meet the demand within the south of the County to minimise the distance crushed rock will need to travel.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 14: What do you think to the draft policy regarding secondary and recycled aggregates?

Representation ID: 32441

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

Support for the MPA in seeking the use of alternative aggregates and the appreciation that there are limits on how far alternatives can substitute primary aggregate. Whilst support for alternative aggregate should be encouraged in the Plan, the contribution should be viewed as a 'bonus' over and above the required amount of primary aggregate. This is reflective of the NPPF (para 204 (b)). The reduction in ash materials from coal fired power stations is also likely to increase the demand for primary aggregate over the Plan period to address this specific resource shortfall.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 18: What do you think of the draft policy to meet demand for industrial dolomite over the plan period?

Representation ID: 32442

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

Reserves of industrial dolomite are of international importance and the resource
itself is scarce with only a small number of sites within the UK. As such there will
always be a need for the resource, therefore the policy should be reworded to state
that: 'Proposals for industrial dolomite extraction will be supported providing that
development does not give rise to any unacceptable levels of environmental impact'.
Whilst additional resource areas do not need to be identified as an allocation, the
resource within Nottinghamshire should be identified within the Plan and recognised
as a proven resource to be safeguarded.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 23:What do you think of the draft policy wording for DM2: Water resources and flood risk?

Representation ID: 32443

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

It is considered that the use of 'detrimentally altered' is not an effective strategy as
there is no quantifiable method by which it can be monitored, nor severity of impact
measured. It is suggested that giving rise to 'unacceptable impacts' would be more
appropriate.
Criterion 3. appears contradictory as in cases where 'risks can be fully mitigated' the proposal would not 'increase flood risk to local communities'. As such, the purpose/ intent of this statement is unclear, and it is recommended that the policy is re-worded.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 24: What do you think of the draft policy wording for DM3: Agricultural land and soil quality

Representation ID: 32444

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

Whilst it is correct to protect and enhance soils (NPPF paragraph 170) and therefore
the best and most versatile agricultural land, the policy is not positively prepared nor
an effective strategy. Minerals can only be worked where they are located and in the
majority of circumstances this is in areas of countryside and often on agricultural
land. Notwithstanding this, with appropriate soil handling strategies the value of soil
resource can be retained, and the land restored for agricultural purposes.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 25: What do you think of the draft policy wording for DM4: Protection and enhancement of biodiversity and geodiversity

Representation ID: 32445

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

Policy is onerous and not in compliance with NPPF, particularly in regard to
the approach on local sites. Paragraph 2 of Policy DM4 should be
amended to reflect the significance of harm to allow a judgement to be made as
opposed to a blanket approach to all impacts. Placing populations of priority species
or areas of priority habitat alongside irreplaceable habitats (criteria d) also does not
distinguish between the value/significance of assets - irreplaceable habitats should
be given greater weight than areas of priority habitat. The distinction needs to be
made to ensure that development has the opportunity to present potential
mitigation or compensation strategies as required by part 2 of the policy.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 26: What do you think of the draft policy wording for DM5: Landscape character

Representation ID: 32446

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

Policy DM5 should reflect the guidance within the NPPF at paragraph 170 and Paragraph 171. It appears that the policy is seeking to place a weight on
the impacts upon landscape character comparable to that of nationally designated
landscapes (of which there are none in Nottinghamshire).
The wording of Policy DM5 appears confused. The policy, as worded, implies that
minerals developments will only be supported if they do not result in an adverse
impact on the landscape and that harmful impacts can be adequately mitigated. In
situations where there is no available alternative to the development and the
development outweighs the landscape interest, the policy still requires that harmful
impacts are adequately mitigated.

Attachments:

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 27: What do you think of the draft policy wording for DM6: Historic environment

Representation ID: 32447

Received: 28/09/2018

Respondent: Tarmac

Agent: Heaton Planning Ltd

Representation Summary:

Paragraph 184 of the NPPF recognises that assets should be conserved in a manner
appropriate to their significance. Part (C) of policy is not consistent with paragraph 197 of the NPPF. Paragraph 197 does not require there to be public benefit.
Paragraph 3.51 acknowledges that in regard to heritage and cultural assets, mineral
development provides major opportunities to understand the County's rich
archaeological heritage. Policy DM6 does not currently recognise this and should
refer to the NPPF requirement of assessment proportionate to the assets
importance (paragraph 189).

Attachments:

For instructions on how to use the system and make comments, please see our help guide.