Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Search representations

Results for Burton Joyce Parish Council search

New search New search

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 1: What do you think of the draft vision and strategic objectives?

Representation ID: 31423

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

The listed policy points on p.13 are generally acceptable, with the significant exception of the 8th point.

Nearness of mineral quarrying sites to end-use sites is of value to the commercial producers since transport costs are a significant element, but the Planning process must take account of those costs to the resident population and to local authorities which are not entered into commercial accounts.

We strongly reject any suggestion that the destruction of farmland to be replaced by even more areas of stagnant open water is anything but harmful to biodiversity in the Trent Vale region.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 2: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for sustainable development?

Representation ID: 31424

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

We accept the principles in this section, and would lay particular emphasis on paragraph 3(a) in SP1. In the Trent Vale region there will be very many cases where the costs of development would significantly and demonstrably outweigh the benefit; not necessarily from the development itself, in the form of new buildings and infrastructure, but in cost to communities of extraction works. We also point out that one aspect of a low-carbon economy, referred to in paragraph 3.6 of the Justification to this section, should imply a low-concrete economy, as set out more fully in answer to Question 5.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 3: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for minerals provision?

Representation ID: 31425

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

We agree with the principles set out in SP2. In particular we approve of the priority being given to extension of existing sites over the development of new sites, and wish to emphasise the second paragraph in SP2, the need for avoidance of the damage of development of new sites.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 4: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for biodiversity led restoration?

Representation ID: 31426

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

While the general principles as set out in SP3 appear benevolent, they may be, and have previously been, used to present a false picture of the effects of minerals extraction as some sort of "gain." Specifically, it is wrong to suggest that there is any gain in the destruction of a diverse farming landscape of mixed pasture and arable land, with trees and hedges, turning it into an open area of stagnant water. Such places are already over-supplied in this area by past workings. Such bodies of water may present health risks, or create dangerous foggy conditions.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 5: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for climate change?

Representation ID: 31427

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

There are two important ways that climate change should affect the Minerals Plan, and both are referred to in Policy SP4. Paragraph 1(a) refers to the desirability of moving to a low carbon economy, but one aspect of such a move not mentioned is the desirability of using less concrete (and consequently less aggregate.)

The second point on climate change is that it is producing greater extremes of weather, including longer periods of very high rainfall. This means areas at risk of flooding are in future at risk of more frequent and more severe potential flooding.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 6: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for sustainable transport?

Representation ID: 31428

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

We would emphasise the point SO5 in the Objectives list in this section, "minimising impact on communities." This is not necessarily best achieved in all cases by barging or by having extraction sites close to end markets.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 7: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for the built, historic and natural environment?

Representation ID: 31429

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

We agree with the Policy SP6 standards, and place particular emphasis on landscape character; flood risk; community amenity. As stated above, mainly in answer to Question 4, we have strong reservations about any claim, such as that at 3.49, that "restoration to wetland" has any meaningful contribution to make to local biodiversity. We strongly support the point made in paragraph 3.58 that the landscape in the Trent Washlands is particularly under pressure.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 8: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for the Nottinghamshire Green Belt?

Representation ID: 31430

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

The Green Belt is not itself designed to provide adequate protection against destructive mineral extraction operations. However, "beneficial use of the Green Belt" must include its landscape character, which is bound to be damaged by mineral working; and especially sand and gravel digging.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 9: What do you think of the draft strategic policy for minerals safeguarding, consultation areas and associated minerals infrastructure?

Representation ID: 31431

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

The greater part of this section is beyond our specific concerns or expertise. However, we view with alarm the reference to the wharf at Colwick, 3.90 and 3.91. The proposal for quarrying at Shelford, part of a revised version of the draft Minerals plan in the consultation and draft plan abandoned in 2017, would have had devastating consequences for Burton Joyce.

Comment

Draft Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan

Question 10: What do you think of the draft policy approach regarding future aggregate provision?

Representation ID: 31432

Received: 05/09/2018

Respondent: Burton Joyce Parish Council

Representation Summary:

Even a fairly small percentage contribution from recycled and secondary aggregates would make a very significant reduction to total extraction requirements.

We are advocates for Option B in the forecast figures in the second box on that page, but of course in the second set of Options we prefer that proposed, A, "Prioritise extensions to existing permitted quarries."

We consider the figure for sand and gravel, 32.30 million tonnes, in Policy MP1, to be an overestimate that can lead to serious but avoidable harm to the area, and we object to the subsequent figures in the tables at 4.10.

For instructions on how to use the system and make comments, please see our help guide.