DM6: Historic Environment

Showing comments and forms 1 to 3 of 3

Support

Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan Publication Version

Representation ID: 240

Received: 07/10/2019

Respondent: Severn Trent Water Ltd

Representation Summary:

DM6 – The allocation around South Muskham is indicated to be in close proximity to Severn
Trent surface water assets. The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection
Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not
available from the EA for this site.

Full text:

Thank you for the opportunity to comment on your consultation. Severn Trent are generally supportive of Polices to protect the environment and water resources, and agree with the principles outlined within the minerals plan to protect ground and surface water from the impacts of mineral extraction, to help to deliver Water Framework Directives, to mitigate the impacts of climate change and flooding, where possible.
There are a number of sites that are indicated to be located in close proximity or intersect with Severn Trent assets:
Potential Mineral Allocation Sites:
 MP2k (Bawtry Road West) – This site falls within a groundwater Source Protection Zone (SPZ) 3 therefore it may pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site is located within the Idle and Torne EA CAMS (Environment Agency Catchment Abstraction Management Strategies) area and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1 below).
 MP2l (Scrooby Thompson Land) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site is located within the Idle and Torne EA CAMS area and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1 below).
 MP2m (Scrooby North) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site is located within the Idle and Torne EA CAMS area and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1 below).
 MP3 (Scrooby Top North) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site is located within the Idle and Torne EA CAMS area and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1 below).
 MP2n (Langford Lowfield North) – The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. No CAMS data is available from the EA for this site.
 MP2o (Besthorpe East) - The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. No CAMS data is available from the EA for this site.
2
 MP7c (Bantycock Quarry South) - the site is indicated to be in close proximity to Severn
Trent surface water assets therefore it may be necessary to have discussions concerning
extraction, to ensure that Severn Trent assets are not adversely effected by operations. The
site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to
pose a risk to groundwater assets. No CAMS data is available from the EA for this site.
 MP3d (Bestwood 2 North) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose
a risk to groundwater assets. This site falls within the Lower Trent & Erewash EA CAMS
area and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing”
(See Note1 below).
 MP2p Mill Hill (near Barton in Fabis) – This minerals extraction site is indicated to be
intersected by Severn Trent surface water assets, therefore discussions with Severn Trent
should be held to ensure that impacts on Severn Trent are appropriately mitigated. The site
does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a
risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available from the EA for this site.
All Permitted Sites April 2019:
 MP2g (Girton) – The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone
therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available
from the EA for this site.
 MP2h (Langford Lowfields) – Indicated to be in close proximity to Severn Trent Surface
Water assets. The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone
therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available
from the EA for this site.
 MP2f (Besthorpe) - Indicated to be in close proximity to Severn Trent Surface Water assets.
The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely
to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available from the EA for this site.
 MP2c (Sturton Le Steeple) - The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source
Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are
not available from the EA for this site.
 MP2a (Newington South) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose
a risk to groundwater assets. This site is located within the Idle and Torne EA CAMS area
and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See
Note1 below).
 MP4a (Nether Langwith) - The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection
Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site falls within the Idle
& Torne EA CAMS area and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not
Available for Licensing” (See Note1 below).
 MP7b (Bantycock Quarry) - the site is indicated to be in close proximity to Severn Trent
assets it may be necessary to have discussions around the extraction, to ensure that Severn
Trent assets are not adversely effected by operations. The site does not fall in a
groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to
groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available from the EA for this site.
 MP6b (Dorket Head – part a) - the site is bounded by Severn Trent assets; we strongly
advise that Severn Trent Water is consulted during permitting to ensure that Severn Trent
assets are not adversely effected by operations. The site does not fall in a groundwater
3
asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets.
CAMS data are not available from the EA for this site.
 MP3a (Burnstump) - the site is indicated to be intersected by Severn Trent assets, it is vital
that discussions are held with Severn Trent to ensure that any impacts on Severn Trent
assets are managed appropriately. The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 and is
approximately 60 m from an SPZ 2 therefore there is a moderate chance it may pose a risk
to groundwater assets. This site falls within the Lower Trent & Erewash EA CAMS area and
is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See
Note1 below).
 MP6b (Dorket Head – part b) - the site is indicated to be intersected by Severn Trent
assets, it is vital that discussions are held with Severn Trent to ensure that any impacts on
Severn Trent assets are managed appropriately. The site does not fall in a groundwater
asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets.
CAMS data are not available from the EA for this site.
 MP7a (Marlaegis Mine) – the site is located in close proximity to Severn Trent assets it may
be necessary to discuss these assets to prevent any detrimental impacts to the Severn Trent
network. The site does not fall in a groundwater asset SPZ therefore it is unlikely to pose a
risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available from the EA for this site.
 MP8a (Two Oaks Farm) - the site is indicated to be bounded by Severn Trent assets, it may
be necessary to discuss the site with Severn Trent to ensure that the development of the site
does not have an adverse impact on Severn Trent assets. The site falls within a groundwater
SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site is also located within the
Idle & Torne EA CAMS area and is designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See
Note1 below).
 MP10a (Yellowstone Quarry) - The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source
Protection Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site falls
within Lower Trent & Erewash EA CAMS area and is also situated within a sub-area
designated as ‘Restricted Water Available for Licensing” (See Note1 below).
 MP3b (Bestwood 2) - The site is indicated to be bounded by Severn Trent Assets,
discussion We strongly recommend that you contact Severn Trent to ensure that Severn
Trent assets are not adversely effected. The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore
it may pose a risk to groundwater assets. This site falls within Lower Trent & Erewash EA
CAMS area and is also situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for
Licensing” (See Note1 below).
 MP2i (East Leake) - the site is located in close proximity to Severn Trent assets it may be
necessary to discuss these assets to prevent any detrimental impacts to the Severn Trent
network. The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore it is
unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available from the EA for
this site.
 MP2e (Cromwell) – This site is indicated to be in close proximity to Severn Trent surface
water assets. The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection Zone therefore
it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not available from the EA
for this site.
 MP3c (Scrooby Top) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a
risk to groundwater assets. This site falls within the Idle & Torne EA CAMS area and is also
situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1
below).
4
 MP2j (Scrooby) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a risk to
groundwater assets. This site falls within the Idle & Torne EA CAMS area and is also
situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1
below).
 MP2b (Finningley) - The site is located within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a
risk to groundwater assets. This site falls within the Idle & Torne EA CAMS area and is also
situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1
below).
 MP2d (Bawtry Road) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a
risk to groundwater assets. This site falls within the Idle & Torne EA CAMS area and is also
situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1
below).
 MP6a (Kirton) - The site falls within a groundwater SPZ 3 therefore it may pose a risk to
groundwater assets. This site falls within the Idle & Torne EA CAMS area and is also
situated within a sub-area designated as ‘Water Not Available for Licensing” (See Note1
below).
South Muskham Archaeological Centre:
 DM6 – The allocation around South Muskham is indicated to be in close proximity to Severn
Trent surface water assets. The site does not fall in a groundwater asset Source Protection
Zone therefore it is unlikely to pose a risk to groundwater assets. CAMS data are not
available from the EA for this site.
Note1 – The specific quarry sites designated above fall within an Environment Agency CAMS subareas
which are marked as either “(Ground) Water Not Available for Licensing” or “Restricted
(Ground) Water Available”. In such areas the EA is unlikely to grant new consumptive abstraction
licences. Even in “(Ground) Water Available for Licensing” areas the EA would request that the
WFD ‘No-Deterioration” principles are followed.
Please keep us informed when your plans are further developed when we will be able to offer more
detailed comments and advice.
For your information we have set out some general guidelines that may be useful to you.
Position Statement
As a water company we have an obligation to provide water supplies and sewage treatment
capacity for domestic flows from future development. It is important for us to work collaboratively
with Local Planning Authorities to provide relevant assessments of the impacts of future
developments. For outline proposals we are able to provide general comments. Once detailed
developments and site specific locations are confirmed by local councils, we are able to provide
more specific comments and modelling of the network if required. For most developments we do not
foresee any particular issues that would prevent the supply of water or sewerage. Where we
consider there may be an issue we would discuss in further detail with the Local Planning Authority.
Where quarries are proposed to be developed or extended, we do not anticipate there will be any
significant need to supply water or sewerage due to the nature of development. If however you
anticipate that there will be a requirement for Severn Trent to provide these services it is strongly
advised that you contact us to ensure that capacity can be made available at the appropriate time.
5
Sewage Strategy
Once detailed plans are available and we have modelled the additional capacity, in areas where sufficient capacity is not currently available and we have sufficient confidence that developments will be built, we will complete necessary improvements to provide the capacity. We will ensure that our assets have no adverse effect on the environment and that we provide appropriate levels of treatment at each of our sewage treatment works.
Surface Water and Sewer Flooding
Whilst we do not anticipate a significant increase in impermeable area, it may be necessary to pump water out of the minerals working area. Severn Trent would anticipate that this will be managed appropriately onsite and discharged through sustainable outfall, without the need to utilise public sewerage network. It is however anticipated that sewerage connections may be required for site offices and welfare facilities.
Groundwater
While most of the proposed locations do not appear to constitute a significant risk to water quality of our assets, there are a few that may constitute risks to groundwater assets. Severn Trent strongly recommends that all appropriate EA guidance is followed with reference to site management and any future abstraction of water to ensure the WFD ‘No-Deterioration’ Principles are followed.
Water Quality
Good quality river water and groundwater is vital for provision of good quality drinking water. We work closely with the Environment Agency and local farmers to ensure that water quality of supplies are not impacted by our or others operations. The Environment Agency’s Source Protection Zone (SPZ) and Safe Guarding Zone policy should provide guidance on development. Any proposals should take into account the principles of the Water Framework Directive and River Basin Management Plan for the Severn River basin unit as prepared by the Environment Agency.
Water Supply
Whilst it is not anticipated that water supply will be required for quarrying operations, we do anticipate some water supply needs for domestic activities associated with site offices and welfare facilities.
We would not anticipate capacity problems within the urban areas of our network, any issues can be addressed through reinforcing our network. However, the ability to support significant development in the rural areas is likely to have a greater impact and require greater reinforcement to accommodate greater demands.
We hope this information has been useful to you and we look forward in hearing from you in the near future.

Support

Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan Publication Version

Representation ID: 260

Received: 10/10/2019

Respondent: Bolsover District Council

Representation Summary:

Provision is made in the Development Management policies for applications to take account of historic and archaeological features (Policy DM6:Historic Environment).

As noted above, Bolsover District Council is not a minerals planning authority. However, insofar as the Minerals Local Plan has the potential to have an impact on assets in Bolsover District, the Council is happy to acknowledge that the Minerals Local Plan has been based on effective joint working in relation to potential cross boundary strategic matters; and that following representations on earlier iterations of the Local Plan these issues have been resolved rather than deferred.
In short, the District Council is satisfied with the engagement that has taken place as the Plan has been developed, and supports the provisions in the Nottinghamshire County Council Minerals Local Plan in relation to the historic environment, particularly Creswell Crags.

Full text:

Dear Sir,
Thank you for the opportunity to comment on the Publication Version of the Nottinghamshire County Council Minerals Local Plan.
It is assumed that Derbyshire County Council as the relevant minerals authority will comment on any substantive issues in relation to the soundness and legal compliance of the Plan.
Bolsover District Council have made representations on previous iterations of the Plan, most recently at the Issues and Options stage of the Plan.
The key concern of the Bolsover District Council throughout the process of plan development has been the need to acknowledge the importance of, and seek the protection of, Creswell Crags. The site is one of the most important archaeological and geological sites in Britain. In response to the consultation on the Issues and Options document, we suggested some changes to the document, including further references to both the historic environment and more specifically Creswell Crags.
The Publication Version of the Nottinghamshire County Council Minerals Plan now contains a section on heritage in the overview of the document (Paragraph 2.14). Strategic Objective 07 relates to the protection and enhancement of historic assets. The section on industrial dolomite provision acknowledges the presence and importance of Creswell Crags. Provision is made in the Development Management policies for applications to take account of historic and archaeological features (Policy DM6:Historic Environment).
As noted above, Bolsover District Council is not a minerals planning authority. However, insofar as the Minerals Local Plan has the potential to have an impact on assets in Bolsover District, the Council is happy to acknowledge that the Minerals Local Plan has been based on effective joint working in relation to potential cross boundary strategic matters; and that following representations on earlier iterations of the Local Plan these issues have been resolved rather than deferred.
In short, the District Council is satisfied with the engagement that has taken place as the Plan has been developed, and supports the provisions in the Nottinghamshire County Council Minerals Local Plan in relation to the historic environment, particularly Creswell Crags.

Support

Nottinghamshire Minerals Local Plan Publication Version

Representation ID: 291

Received: 10/10/2019

Respondent: IGas Energy

Representation Summary:

IGas previously commented on this policy. The changes to the policy and justification are now considered to be in line with the NPPF and are supported.

Full text:

See attachment